Sky High vs Lash Paradise: Which Mascara Is Better?

Two of the best-selling drugstore mascaras, two very different looks. Here’s how Sky High and Lash Paradise compare so you can pick the one that matches the lashes you want.

Heads up: This post has affiliate links. If you buy through them, Marcy Vanity earns a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The short version: Sky High is about length and separation. Lash Paradise is about volume and fluff. Both are usually under $15.

Quick verdict

	Maybelline Sky High	L’Oréal Lash Paradise
Best for	Long, separated, “fluttery” lashes	Thick, full, dramatic lashes
Brush	Flexible, thin brush that reaches the corners	Big, soft, fluffy brush
Look	Natural to lengthened	Fuller and bolder
Clumping	Low	A little more if you layer
Waterproof version	Yes	Yes

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High

What it does: the flexible brush grabs every lash, even tiny corner ones, and stretches them long. Lashes stay separated, not spidery.

Pick it if: you want long, natural-looking lashes, have short or sparse lashes, or hate clumps.

Check today’s price on Maybelline Sky High →

L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise

What it does: the big, soft brush loads on product for a full, feathery, voluminous look.

Pick it if: you want bold lashes for nights out, photos or a “false lash” effect.

Check today’s price on L’Oréal Lash Paradise →

Which one should you buy?

Straight or short lashes: Sky High. Curl first, then apply.
Want drama: Lash Paradise.
Sensitive or watery eyes: either in a tubing or waterproof version, and remove gently.
Both? Many people do Sky High first for length, then one coat of Lash Paradise on the tips.

Shop heated eyelash curlers on Amazon →

Tips for better mascara

Curl your lashes first.
Wiggle at the root, then pull up.
Two thin coats beat one thick coat.
Replace mascara about every 3 months.

FAQ

Is Sky High or Lash Paradise better for length?
Sky High. It’s known for long, separated lashes.

Which is better for volume?
Lash Paradise, thanks to its big, fluffy brush.

Do they smudge?
Some people get smudging with any regular mascara. If that’s you, try the waterproof version.

Keep reading

Pin this mascara face-off, and follow Marcy Vanity on Pinterest for more drugstore makeup comparisons.

Save this for later 📌

Maybelline Sky High vs. L’Oréal Lash Paradise: Which Viral Drugstore Mascara Wins?