Lancôme Lash Idôle vs. Maybelline Sky High vs. essence Lash Princess: Is the $5 Mascara Good Enough?

Marcy Vanity is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases — it never costs you extra.

Mascara is the one makeup product almost everyone buys, and right now it’s the most-searched makeup item on Amazon. Two drugstore mascaras sit in Amazon’s top 4 best-selling makeup products, while Lancôme’s Lash Idôle is on sale during the Amazon Holiday Beauty Event (makeup flash deals run Oct 19–20). So: is the $22 tube worth it, or does the $5 one do the job?

At a glance

	Lancôme Lash Idôle	Maybelline Sky High	essence Lash Princess
Price (at time of writing)	$22.50 (reg. $30)	$10.80	$4.97
Best for	Lift + volume, polished finish	Length + “lash extension” look	Big volume on a tiny budget
Amazon rating	4.4★ (11K+ ratings)	4.5★ (190K+ ratings)	4.3★ (419K+ ratings)
Popularity	40K+ bought last month	#2 best seller in Makeup	#4 best seller in Makeup
	Check price →	Check price →	Check price →

💎 The Splurge: Lancôme Lash Idôle — $22.50

Lash Idôle is built for lift: a curved brush that pushes lashes up and fans them out, with a lightweight, smudge-resistant formula. It’s the pick if you want lashes that look curled and defined without looking clumpy. At regular price it’s $30; on sale this week, it’s a good time to try a prestige mascara for less.

Choose it if: you have straight lashes that won’t hold a curl, or you want a prestige mascara at a discount.

💰 The Save: Maybelline Sky High — $10.80

Sky High is the mascara that made people stop buying expensive ones. The flexible bristle brush reaches every lash, including the tiny corner ones, for serious length. With nearly 200,000 ratings and a top-2 spot in Amazon’s makeup best sellers, it’s the safest buy on this list. (Deciding between drugstore favorites? See our Sky High vs. Lash Paradise showdown.)

Choose it if: length is your goal and you want the best value-for-performance.

🏷️ The Steal: essence Lash Princess — $4.97

Under $5 with over 400,000 ratings. Lash Princess’s fiber brush builds thick, false-lash volume fast, and it’s vegan and cruelty-free. The trade-off: it can get a little clumpy if you over-layer, so two coats max.

Choose it if: you want volume on a budget, or you like to replace mascara often (recommended every ~3 months anyway).

📌 Save this to your Pinterest board for later!

The verdict

• Best overall value: Maybelline Sky High — length that rivals mascaras three times the price.
• Best splurge (this week): Lancôme Lash Idôle — grab it while it’s on sale.
• Best under $5: essence Lash Princess — hard to beat for volume per dollar.

Since mascara should be replaced every few months, the smart move is to keep a drugstore favorite for daily wear and save the splurge for when it goes on sale — like right now.

Prices and ratings were accurate at the time of writing and can change. Check Amazon for the current price.